web analytics
November 21, 2014 / 28 Heshvan, 5775
At a Glance
Blogs
Sponsored Post
IDC Herzliya Campus A Day on Campus

To mark IDC Herzliya’s 20th anniversary, we spent a day following Prof. Uriel Reichman, IDC’s founder and president, and Jonathan Davis, VP for External Relations, around its delightful campus.



Whose Judaism is it Anyway?

The tragedy that we face today is that everyone thinks they are the sole possessors of the answer.
Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik

Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik

Note from Harry Maryles: Every once in a while I will receive a request from one of my readers to publish an essay they have written. My response usually is to send it and if I like it, I will publish it. These essays do not necessarily have to agree with me lock stock and barrel. They can be opposition pieces to what my stated views are. But they cannot advocate positions that I am diametrically opposed to. More often than not, these submissions are rejected for a variety of reasons – among them: they may not measure up to my publishing standards; or they may not be appropriate subjects for my blog; or are so off the wall that they are embarrassing. But every once in a while a submission not only meets my minimum standards,they supersede them. Usually those submissions are from a professional writers who have either published books or articles before. But not always. Sometimes I receive a submission out of the blue that is quite exceptional in both style and content. Today’s guest post is by one such individual. He is all of 15 years old. Here in part is the bio he submitted:

My name is Michael Weiner, I am 15 years old, and currently live in Lower Merion, Pennsylvania. I go to school at Kohelet Yeshiva High School. I moved here from Northern California just a few months ago, in order to go to a religious high school. I went to a Jewish community school from K-8, where I and my brother were 2 out of 3 religiously observant kids. It was, to say the least, quite an experience! I have gone to a Moshava summer camp for the past 4 years, and am currently involved in Bnei Akiva. I consider myself to be Modern Orthodox, and a Zionist, although I don’t hesitate to criticize Israel if I feel it’s necessary.

I am a huge admirer of the Rav, and his writings. Reading ‘The Lonely Man of Faith’ greatly changed the way I view God, Judaism, and life in general. Today, I am most likely going to go to YU, but secular college is not out of the window, because I believe that a secular collegiate experience has many important positive aspects.

However, regardless of one’s lifestyle choices, they must always remain a Jew above all else. This entails being Kovei’ah Zman Ittim, and infusing all that you do in your daily life with a perspective filtered by halacha and Jewish values (however you define that, be it Tikkun Olam or Talmud Torah).

One word. Wow! He also has his own blog. His post follows unedited in its entirety:

Whose Judaism is Anyways?

The title of this post is a question that has no one answer. The tragedy that we face today is that everyone thinks they are the sole possessors of the answer, and that their way of practicing Judaism is undoubtedly more meaningful, more traditional, and ultimately more authentic. This, in my opinion, is the greatest barrier to achdus in the frum community, and general Jewish community at large.

Simply stated, it’s an inability to recognize that Judaism is multi-faceted, halachah is not monolithic, and that for thousands of years, Jews have looked, ate, talked, and sometimes even behaved differently then each other. This is historical fact. During most of the current galus from Israel, we have been different. These differences however, are not the obstacle to unity. The obstacle to unity is the failure to recognize that these differences are normal, and trivial.

In the early years of the 20th century, Agudas Yisroel was formed. This was one of the very first organizations where Chassidim and Misnagdim worked together to find creative solutions to community problems. The Gedolei Yisrael, and laymen of that generation understood that the powerful Haskalah movement was a force that needed to be reckoned with. It presented dangers that made it necessary for a wide variety of Jews to come together and decide how best to respond to such a threat.

The Chafetz Chaim, the Gerrer Rebbe, the Radzhiner Rebbe, and Rav Chaim Ozer Gradzinski decided that enough was enough. Achdus within the religious community was the only way to stand a chance against the roaring fire of modernity that was quickly consuming all of Europe, eventually reaching even the closeted Pale of Settlement, and other Jewish ghettoes.

Today, we face a worldwide Jewish community that is arguably more fractured than it has ever been in the history of Judaism. Reconstructionist, Reform, and Conservative Jews are completely ignored by the frum community. In turn, the more liberal forms of Judaism often push back against Orthodox control of the rabbinate, and halacha. Modern Orthodox Jews are considered kofrim by a great many Chassidim. Anyone who goes to YU is demonized by the right-wing yeshivish community.

Neturei Karta is hated by everyone. Satmar is also disliked by many Modern and Centrist Orthodox Jews because of their views regarding Israel. In Israel, most secular Jews find the idea that Chareidim can get out of army service anathema to their sense of civic duty and pride. Some Chareidim in Israel consider the Israeli government to be comparable to the Nazis rule!

Because of Satmar’s power and influence, they get accomodated by Agudah, which is supposed to represent everyone! In certain extreme frum communities, women cannot wear red, own a cellphone, go to college, learn gemara, wear pants, walk around with normal hair, or talk to men. In others, all these behaviors are tolerated, and encouraged.

All this fighting, and I haven’t even mentioned Chabad… So the big question is, what will it take for the Jewish people to become united? Halacha leaves much room for creativity and flexibility. In Jewish theology as well, no one has a monopoly on truth. The Rambam can argue with the Raavad and the Ramban. Centuries later, the Rav, Emmanuel Levinas, Rabbi David Hartman, and the Satmar Rebbe can all have divergent theological positions while still remaining Orthodox Jews.

This is, in my view, one of the most beautiful aspects of Judaism. However, in recent times, people that don’t dress, speak, or look a certain way are thrown out of certain communities. It is a fact that if you are in Lakewood and don’t wear a white shirt or a black hat, you will not get good shidduchim. The fact that the girls you get to date rest on your clothing attire choices is ludicrous. And it’s just as ludicrous when the Satmar Rebbe wrote that the Holocaust occurred in retribution for Zionism and the Haskalah. And it’s just as ludicrous when modern orthodox Jews make blanket generalizations about ultra-Orthodox Jews.

Tolerance is a Jewish value. The Gemara (Eiruvin 13) brings down the dictum of Eilu V’Eilu, which practically means that in terms of halachic practice, both can be right. With that said, I turn the question to you. What is the single most important thing we can do right now to increase unity within Klal Yisrael? If you have a good answer, share it with everyone in the comments below.

Visit Emes Ve-Emunah.

About the Author: Michael Weiner is a high school student at Kohelet Yeshiva High School.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

6 Responses to “Whose Judaism is it Anyway?”

  1. Jay Kitainik says:

    1.The young man should be more careful with his grammar and spelling.
    2. It is the height of arrogance of a 15-year old boy to call an opinion of the Satmar rebbe ludicrous.
    3. Where does the Agudah accommodate Satmar?
    4. I would not refer to David Hartman as Orthodox anymore. (See the latest issue of Jewish Action).

  2. Jay Kitainik says:

    1.The young man should be more careful with his grammar and spelling.
    2. It is the height of arrogance of a 15-year old boy to call an opinion of the Satmar rebbe ludicrous.
    3. Where does the Agudah accommodate Satmar?
    4. I would not refer to David Hartman as Orthodox anymore. (See the latest issue of Jewish Action).

  3. Michael Weiner says:

    Dear Mr. Kitainik,

    Thank you for your thoughtful comment. Here are my responses to each of your points.

    1. My apologies. Grammar was never my forte. As for spelling, perhaps you are right. However, I did win my school's spelling bee in 6th grade, and that should account for something! All joking aside, as I'm in 9th grade, I don't have an editor, so please allow for some mistakes.

    2. The Satmar Rebbe zt"l was famous throughout the world for his Torah learning and strict adherence to halacha. In these aspects, I greatly admire and respect him. However, regarding his Holocaust theology and opinion regarding Israel today, I disagree. The overwhelming majority of Orthodox Rabbis and gedolim today would disagree with his stance on Israel.

    3. The Agudah accomodated Satmar most recently by canceling their internet filter expo that was supposed to happen at the asifa last spring. Because of Satmar's total opposition to the internet even with filters, it was canceled.

    4. Rabbi David Hartman is a musmach of YU and is highly regarded in academia in the fields of philosophy and theology. Whether his personal viewpoints can be defined as 'Orthodox' (which is, after all, a pretty large label) is up for debate, but he is at least a lot more right wing than most Conservative or Reform Jews.

  4. As a lifelong Mormon I found this post fascinating. Thank you for the insights into the Jewish people. Our faith teaches that God has been revealing Himself and choosing prophets as far back as Adam, and that the Abrahamic Covenant, renewed through Israel, is continually renewed through every "dispensation" to His People, every time He calls another Prophet. From Abraham to Israel to Moses, Isaiah, David, Solomon, and so on. Each new prophet is a new "dispensation," a new calling out for His People, and a new opportunity for the gathering of Israel, which has, through the promises of Abraham, been spread through all the world.

    Again, thank you, and I look forward to reading more.

  5. As a lifelong Mormon I found this post fascinating. Thank you for the insights into the Jewish people. Our faith teaches that God has been revealing Himself and choosing prophets as far back as Adam, and that the Abrahamic Covenant, renewed through Israel, is continually renewed through every "dispensation" to His People, every time He calls another Prophet. From Abraham to Israel to Moses, Isaiah, David, Solomon, and so on. Each new prophet is a new "dispensation," a new calling out for His People, and a new opportunity for the gathering of Israel, which has, through the promises of Abraham, been spread through all the world.

    Again, thank you, and I look forward to reading more.

  6. If you read Joseph Campbell's Occidental Mythology you learn that:

    There is a great tension between the historical sacred consensus of the Middle East and the individualism of the West.

    The sacred consensus model predates Judaism by thousands of years. In Assyria and Babylon the Great King could do no wrong and the sacred law of the King had to be followed to the letter.

    In time these two opposing trends influenced the culture of the other side.

    Rabbinic Judaism tells a story of why the Temple Mount was chosen by G-d. It tells about how two brothers cared more about the other one than themselves.

    Wearing white shirts and black hats is the sacred consensus at Lakewood.

    There is also a sacred consensus at Y.U. You will not see a lot of streimels or capotes there.

    I wish you well, you are the future generation of Jews may you always learn and have an open mind and an open heart.

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Binyamin and Chaya Maryles, uncle and aunt of Emes Ve-Emunah author Harry Maryles.
Current Top Story
Colleagues of the hanged Arab bus driver whose death continues to be referred to as murder despite autopsy finding of suicide. These are Arab drivers of Egged buses, claiming they suffer discrimination by Israelis.
Arab Pathologist Singing New Tune: Murder (By Jews) Not Suicide
Latest Blogs Stories
President Ruby Rivlin

President Rivlin’s recent statements are only half right, and that’s why he’s completely wrong.

i_love_jerusalem

This is our song “Learn to Love;” May joy and light be restored to Jerusalem speedily in our days.

Free-Jonathan-Pollard-Poster

I have a dream…President Obama will go to that prison, Pardon Jonathan Pollard and set him free

Rabbi-Twersky-112114

The burden of proof that a person is against Israel but not anti-Semitic rests on that person.

Bibi’s promising a good battle, not a victory in the war; We need to WIN the war against terrorism!

For 1000s of years it was perfectly OK for Jews to pray on Herod’s Extension of the Temple Mount.

The focus on the “Occupation” since 1967 is yet another invention to justify hatred and murder.

It should be clear Israel’s existence is not the real issue; the issue is Islamic fundamentalism.

But I am not afraid.I know this is Jewish land, not because of UN/foreign gov’ts saying we can exist

A grassroots initiative of hundreds of Chareidim from Har Nof is underway to attend the funeral of Zidan Saif and to pay their respects to the fallen policeman and to the Druze community in the village of Yanuch-Jat in Northern Israel.

Discover the world of NY high society and its intrigue.

A Jew is no more exempt in this war by living in the US or UK than I am enlisted by living in Efrat

Officer Zidan Sayif saved lives in the Har Nof Massacre, but was shot in the head and is now fighting for his life.

“Y.E.” a United Hatzalah paramedic was injured while treating the wounded under fire in the Har Nof Massacre.

It is time the leaders in Israel and the world realize this has nothing to do with settlements or the Temple Mount or a fake claim of occupation and everything to do with radical Islamic barbarism!

The Leftist Israeli media has always been unabashedly political;To them “objective”=”in my opinion”

More Articles from Michael Weiner
orthodox boy

Pirkei Avot teaches: ‘who is wise? One who learns from all people.’

Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik

The tragedy that we face today is that everyone thinks they are the sole possessors of the answer.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/blogs/haemtza/whose-judaism-is-it-anyway/2012/12/27/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: