Chillul Tefila Bifarhesia, as well as halachicly challenged verbiage and dress, are external manifestations of a critical lack of personal yiras shomayim which has lethal consequences.
Not since the height of the Cold War has our nation been this wary of foreigners, or this uncertain as to how to best respond to external threats to our national security.
Illegal immigration remains a major concern, both in terms of how to prevent and what to do to with the estimated twelve million illegal immigrants who have already entered the country. According to a recent New York Times/CBS News poll, the overwhelming majority of Americans think their country’s immigration policies need to be seriously overhauled. And despite vigorous protests against Arizona’s stringent new immigration enforcement law, a majority of Americans support it, even though they acknowledge it may lead to racial profiling.
Still, Americans remain deeply divided about what to do to address the immigration conundrum. According to the poll, the public broadly agrees (78 percent) the country must do more along its border to keep illegal immigrants out. This consensus fractures, however, on the question of the exact role of states in enforcing immigration law, which is normally a federal responsibility.
Fifty-seven percent of those polled said the federal government, not the states, should determine the laws addressing illegal immigration. But 51 percent said the Arizona law, which gives local police officers broad power to detain and check the status of people they suspect are in the country illegally, was “about right” in its approach to the problem. Thirty-six percent said it went too far and nine percent said it did not go far enough.
Another concern for Americans is the scourge of terrorism that increasingly threatens this country. Faisal Shahzad’s near-success in detonating explosives in Times Square was just one in a series of planned and/or executed terrorist plots designed to intimidate the American people. Together, they have reinforced in the national psyche awareness that Islamic militarism is alive and well and carrying out its insidious agenda.
Apparently even our government officials do not have much confidence in our ability to address this pressing issue. House Republican leader John Boehner recently accused the Obama administration of not having a good plan to prevent domestic terrorist attacks. “Frankly most of us believe that the strategy ought to be preventing such attacks,” said Boehner, “not counting on our luck to catch them at the last moment.”
And even when we are fortunate enough to have averted tragedy, we cannot seem to agree on how to treat the suspects once they’re in custody. Civil libertarians continue to insist that suspected terrorists be read their Miranda rights like all other miscreants, despite the fact that this protection will typically keep law enforcement officials from gaining valuable intelligence about terrorist operatives.
Thankfully, even the Obama administration is waking up to the realization that individual rights sometimes must be pushed aside when public safety is at risk. Attorney General Eric Holder recently told ABC’s “This Week” that while “the [Miranda] system we have in place has proven to be effective,” the Obama administration is open to modifying such protections to deal with the “threats that we now face.”
Clearly, a more coherent legislative strategy is needed to address this growing problem. However, we as American Jews must be hopeful that such legislation will not co-opt extremist positions such as the recent proposal by Connecticut Senator Joe Lieberman that American terrorists be stripped of their citizenship.
The concept is inherently flawed because it supposes that naturalized terrorists will be deterred from their ideological mission by the prospect of losing their American citizenship. Such an assumption is highly questionable, particularly when their missions are designed to result in their own deaths. And even if such a threat did concern them, they could rest comfortably knowing it is quite difficult for law enforcement officials to identify the next would-be American terrorist (officials say there was nothing in Shahzad’s background check that would have raised any red flags).
More significantly, Lieberman, as a Jew, should be wary of introducing any such legislation. After all, it wasn’t such a long time ago that the Nazis decried German Jews as enemies of the Fatherland and stripped them of their citizenship, a major step in achieving their answer to the Jewish Question.
And while we understandably bristle at any comparison between this historically benevolent and hospitable country and Nazi Germany, apparently not everyone sees it that way. In the words of Los Angeles councilman Paul Koretz, “We can’t let this advance any further. It is absolutely dangerous.”
The U.S. has seen its fair share of discriminatory xenophobes who at different points in time went to great lengths to keep foreigners far from American shores, from the 19th century Know Nothing Party and the KKK to the internment of Japanese-Americans during World War II.
Most damaging for Jews desperately seeking asylum from abject poverty, persecutions, the ravages of war-torn Europe and Nazism were the Emergency Immigration Act of 1921 and the Johnson-Reed Immigration Act of 1924. These laws slowed Jewish immigration down significantly.
Jews who did manage to reach America during this period, like those who had arrived earlier, were subjected to virulent anti-Semitism as showcased during the Leo Frank trial, in Henry Ford’s Dearborn Independent, and on Father Charles Coughlin’s popular radio program. They were also forced to endure a quieter but no less damaging anti-Semitism that expressed itself in the marketplace, in social clubs, in universities admissions offices and in residency restrictions. It took several decades for many of those anti-Jewish attitudes to begin to dissipate.
Let us hope our legitimate security concerns will not make it all too easy for fear and paranoia to replace fact and civility.
About the Author: Rabbi Naphtali Hoff is Head of School at Torah Day School of Atlanta. He can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org.
You must log in to post a comment.
Neither Secretary of State Kerry nor the president he serves seem to understand Russia’s goals in the Middle East.
You might think that six Khamenei followers might split the hardline vote but don’t worry as that will be taken care of in the ballot-counting if necessary.
To assume that your opponents have any decency, as the Republicans habitually do, is to be left behind in Politics 1.0.
Ahmadinejad may plan to reveal proof that the 2009 elections were rigged if his candidate’s registration for presidential candidacy is not accepted.
With a ‘friend’ like Erdogan, Obama’s policy toward Syria, Iran, the advance of revolutionary Islamism, and the Israel-Palestinian “peace process,” is in serious trouble.
The media loved Obama, but it discovered early on that he did not love it back.
Are we to believe that these Jews who were devout and pious were being punished?
How far the PA will go to present the lie as the truth and the truth as a lie? Its claim that Jesus was a Palestinian is old hat. But now the “resurrection” also refers to “the Palestinian state.”
The progressive consolidation imagines that organization can contain the messier side of man.
The Russian Yakhont missiles already delivered to Syria threaten Israel Navy ships carrying out vital missions in the Mediterranean.
Islamism represents the transformation of Islamic faith into a political ideology.
America could be said to be building a united front against Iran, but at what price?
The Japanese do not feel the need to apologize to Muslims for the negative way in which they relate to Islam.
Palestinian youths from Hebron, though, who met with Israelis near Bethlehem to share their problems and insights have been forced to issue a statement distancing themselves from the meeting.
Benghazi isn’t likely to keep Hillary out of the Democratic field in 2016, but after 2008, she is justifiably paranoid.
Earlier this month the London Games were all the rage. Tens of thousands descended upon Great Britain’s crown jewel to witness the Olympics and cheer for their respective countrymen.
After three-plus years of economic challenge and uncertainty, we remain anxious for positive news, the kind that will finally let us believe the worst is fully behind us. Unfortunately, the outlook for the 2012 global economy remains uninspiring: recession in Europe, anemic growth in the U.S. and a sharp slowdown in China and other emerging-market economies all weigh on economist forecasts.
Asara B’Teves, the 10th of Teves, commemorates the beginning of the siege of Jerusalem by the Babylonian ruler Nebuchadnezzar that ultimately culminated with the First Temple’s destruction on the 9th of Av the following year.
The twelve-member bipartisan congressional “super committee” on spending cuts formally conceded defeat late last month, after failing to reach common ground on the issues of tax increases and spending cuts.
The morning of November 8 (11 Cheshvan) was an unusual one for me. I had awakened early in preparation for a flight out of town to deliver a presentation at a teacher in-service program in the New York area. I scrolled through my inbox only to learn that Rabbi Nosson Tzvi Finkel, rosh yeshiva of Mir Jerusalem, had passed away hours before.
A recent article in The Jewish Week brought to light something that has been afflicting the Orthodox community for some time now: teenage texting on Shabbos. The practice is becoming increasingly prevalent, especially but in no way exclusively, among Modern Orthodox teens.
Marriage is under assault again in this country, as fewer adults choose to tie the matrimonial knot while the Left continues to lend civil and economic credence to unions of same-sex partners.
Hashem said to Moshe, “Write this for a memorial in a book, and recite it in the ears of Yehoshua; for I will completely erase the remembrance of Amalek from under heaven” (Shemos 17:14). For most of our history, the struggle between the Jewish people and Amalek was seen as an external one, pitting the [...]
Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/opinions/stranger-danger/2010/05/26/
Scan this QR code to visit this page online: