Photo Credit: Walla screenshot
The Duma defense team in the Petah Tikva Magistrate's court

UPDATE: The Magistrate’s Court in Petah Tikva on Monday ordered the release of a suspect in the Duma arson murder case after it turned out police had no evidence against him, and was only planning to drag his arrest with a two-year-old charge, according to Honenu legal aid society. The court ordered the suspect be released to house arrest, but delayed carrying out the order, to give police time to prepare an appeal.

The following is our earlier story on the case, when it was not yet clear whether the court would accept the police request for yet another remand against the suspect, who had spent 29 days in his cell without seeing a lawyer or a judge:


For the first time after months without any movement on the Duma arson murders, and after a month of detaining a number of Jewish youths, some of them minors, as suspects in the case, while keeping a gag order on all press references, on Monday the Shabak and the State Attorney have issued a “prosecutor’s statement” to the court against one of the suspects, the Honenu legal aid society announced. As it happens, this first suspect endured 29 days without an attorney, had bouts of vomiting during his interrogation, allegedly due to the brutality of the physical inducement used against him to confess.

A prosecutor’s statement to the court against a given suspect indicates the intention to file an indictment. Issuing the statement is designed to allow law enforcement agencies to complete the indictments, which requires keeping the suspect in detention in order to prevent obstruction. In a sense, it’s the prosecution telling the courts, We know we’ve kept the suspect in for a very long time without offering a shred of real evidence, but if you let us keep him just a little while longer we promise you an indictment.

Except that in this case, after so much has been said about the Shabak squeezing out the detainees’ confessions, having all the facts and weaving them into devastating charges as we speak, it turned out the prosecutor’s statement of intent is not related to the arson murder in Duma, but to a different case altogether.

According to attorney Hai Haber representing the young man who threatens Bart Simpson’s detention record, the young man is not, for the moment, a suspect in the Duma case, but in a brawl he had with a Bedouin close to two years ago.

In what appears like a page from a dirty trick play book, Police are now asking to extend the young man’s detention by a few more days to prepare the indictment for the brawl, but Haber is asking the court to release him immediately, in light of the suffering his client has already endured during his month-long incognito incarceration. Haber is insisting his client be sent home based on his shaky mental state following the interrogation, and the fact that ultimately the purported case against him is based on an incident that occurred a long time ago, when he was a minor, and in which he claims self-defense.

According to Honenu, this sudden shift has more to do with the Shabak looking to justify the brutal treatment of a suspect who turned out not to be connected to the Duma case—by pinning to him an ancient episode from his teen years. In one interrogation, the suspect alleges, a Shabak interrogator grabbed his head and pulled him back until he started vomiting, after being interrogated continuously for 3 days without sleep. Should there be a separate parliamentary investigation of the Shabak in this instance, proving the lad was guilty of something couldn’t hurt.

Meanwhile, Israelis on both sides of the aisle are awaiting breathlessly the real indictments in the Duma case, and as these are, supposedly, being prepared for release towards the weekend, to become fodder for the Friday night news shows, some social network sites are already passing rumors of a new “Champagne,” the code name for the Shabak agent-provocateur who guided the Late Yitzhak Rabin’s murderer, Yigal Amir.


Previous articleOn The Bookshelf
Next articleStories Of The Dubno Maggid brings you the latest in Jewish news from around the world. Stay up to date by following up on Facebook and Twitter. Do you have something noteworthy to report? Submit your news story to us here.


  1. Shameful!. Israel’s Government, especially Netanyahu will await critical Judgement from our Creator! This is FORBIDDEN!. Instead of THROWING out ALL the Palestinian Arabs from the Jewish Land of Israel, you have Greedy, Selfish politicians like “Netanyahu” who tries with all his might, to keep His status in the Knesset. This is why there won’t be any MASHIACH anytime soon. Enough is Enough. Jew Bloodshed every day, spilled on the ground of the most treasured land of HaShem. GO’AL NEFESH!

  2. They arrested people they knew were both innocent and hated. They arrested them without any charge. The defendants were not permitted to see their lawyers. They were (are) tortured into making a confession. Could you imagine this in the United States? "The Only Democracy in the Middle East". And the moon is made of green cheese.

  3. This is absolutely bizarre! Asking for an extension of a man's detention in the investigation of an arson case on the grounds that he has a case to answer for an previous incident for which he was not charged is Kafkaesque. It is clearly an abuse of the investigative process. Equally seriously, it leads one to suspect that the authorities have no evidence to put before a judge and that the accused are falsely accused for political ends. If that is so, it would be a tragedy for Israeli justice and democracy.

Comments are closed.

Loading Facebook Comments ...