Ohio Jew Tossed Out of Sen. Brown Event for Asking about J Street Funding
Latest update: September 23rd, 2012
print
tell a friend
Senator Sherrod Brown
Photo Credit: Campaign image
See an update at the end of this report.
In what originally was supposed to be a slam dunk, US Senator Sherrod Brown’s race for reelection in Ohio against the youthful Republican Josh Mandell may instead be turning into a squeaker, and Brown is none too happy about it.
Brown originally had as much as a 17 percentage point lead, but according to a report in Bloomberg, several polls last month showed the race to be deadlocked. Mandell claims the race has become intense because Ohioans are increasingly turned off by the “ultra-liberal, hyper-partisan” Brown, while Brown claims that millions of dollars in negative ads have been run against him by “outside, undisclosed interest groups.”
One Ohioan found out just how testy this race has made Sherrod Brown. Following a talk he gave at the Dayton, Ohio Chamber of Commerce on Tuesday, September 18, Senator Brown invited questions. There were a few tough questions put to the Senator by business owners opposed to President Obama’s healthcare legislation, and a softball question about how to contact the Senator’s office.
And then 32-year old Ohio native Joel Griffith stood up. Griffith said, “I’m a proud Jewish American and I’m concerned that the single biggest entity funding you is J Street. J Street has given you $60,000, and as you know, J Street is funded by an attorney for the Saudi Embassy and has also been funded by the producer of one of the most anti-Semitic films ever made …” but Griffith was not allowed to finish his question. The Senator’s first response was that Griffith’s was “clearly a political question.”
True, but the Senator is a politician who was engaging in politics. The political question doctrine only forecloses the judicial branch from addressing a particular issue. In fact, political questions are reserved exclusively to the legislative branch of which Senator Brown is hoping to remain a part.
But as Griffith sought to continue asking his question, and paused to ask whether it was okay if he filmed the exchange, Senator Brown cut him off and told Griffith to “talk to that man in the back of the room who is Jewish,” because that Jewish man supports Brown and “knows that I am pro-Israel.”
On his third attempt to get out his question, the frustrated Griffith began once again, saying, “What do you say to those Jewish Americans who are very concerned…” But again, Brown cut him off. The Senator instead told Griffith what he should do before Brown would answer him. Senator Brown told his constituent, “You find out where the $18 million came from that is funding ads against me,” and said Griffith could then come back and ask his question next year. The Senator then wrapped up that portion of the program.
Griffith waited patiently while the Senator remained in the room speaking informally to others who were present at the event. Just as Griffith was once again about to ask the senator about the J Street funding, a Chamber of Commerce official approached and told him he had to leave the premises because it was a “private event.” However, the event had been publicized, Griffith had informed the Chamber that he would be attending the event, and the Chamber had confirmed his response.
The Jewish Press caught up with Griffith the day after his failed efforts to draw out the Ohio Senator on his J Street funding. Griffith is a lawyer by training but is currently an investor with Avatar Securities.
The J Street funding issue was so important to him, Griffith said, because “J Street has been trying to promote policies that are inconsistent with Israel’s security and against America’s security, and yet politicians who work with them then claim they are pro-Israel because they are siding with a Jewish organization.”
Griffith pointed out that “J Street gives more money to Senator Brown than any other single entity, including Ohio State University,” which he thought was very odd, especially considering Brown’s complaint about outside money playing an outsized role in his opponent’s war chest.
Griffith is a political conservative and is very concerned about the role of anti-American and anti-Israel efforts on Capital Hill. Although Brown has never opposed the funding of aid to Israel, Griffith was particularly bothered by his refusal to sign a bi-partisan “Peace Principles” letter that was circulated in 2009 by AIPAC and which was signed by more than three quarters of all senate members.
tell a friendAbout the Author: Lori Lowenthal Marcus is the US correspondent for The Jewish Press. She is a recovered lawyer who previously practiced First Amendment law and taught in Philadelphia-area graduate and law schools.
You might also be interested in:
You must log in to post a comment.
No Responses to “Ohio Jew Tossed Out of Sen. Brown Event for Asking about J Street Funding”
1
Loading ...
This is the most deressing election cycle. The lies are overwhelming the truth. Mr. Griffith deserved a respectful answer from Sherrod Brown, instead he was rebuffed. The president uses mockery and lies against Romney.
There is no longer any truth to be had.
If Sen. Brown is so bad, how come he cosponsored this:
http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c112:S.RES.380:
If Brown is associated, funded with J-street he cannot be in reality pro-Israel. Are you a J Streeter Charlie?
No. I detest J Street. And note my earlier comment.
Does the fact that Brown's opponent takes money from the Koch brothers make him a John Bircher?
During his time in Washington, Brown has voted against foreign aid for Israel on 5 separate occasions. He actually voted to CUT foreign aid to Israel in the highly controversial 'Campbell Amendment' (H.R.1486). Brown is the ONLY US senator endorsed by anti-Israel J-Street who have raised $100,000 for his campaign. On top of all this, Brown has a long record of refusing to sign bi-partisan letters of support of Israel. All of these facts are legitimate questions into just who Brown is. If Brown is not afraid of answering these facts, why have Joel Griffith ignored and removed?
may devils drag brown to hell in pain.
Elizabeth Levy, you may remember Joel Griffith, protagonist in this story, from this summer's YJC Israel trip!
we need to throw ALL THE SENATORS AND CONGRESSMEN OUT. They work for US NOT THE OTHER WAY AROUND!
i'm not Jewish and this pi$$es me of. HOW DARE HE TREAT A CONSTITUENT THAT WAY.
do you feel the same way when paul ryan has constituants forcably removed from his town halls when they ask questions he doesn't like or call him a liar, which of course he is?
YES I DO Edward. We are supposed to have these representatives as an avenue to give redress to our grievances. THIS IS NOT SOMETHING PEOPLE SHOULD BE DRAGGED OFF IN HANDCUFFS FOR.
this is looking more and more like a communist state. NOT what I took an oath before almighty G_d to defend.
Edward Lobel I saw that Paul Ryan video. Instantly turned me off.
well then we agree!
the soros owned "j"udenrein street fully supports the obama agenda of eradicating the First Amendment and proving yet again that the "transparency" chairman barack promised was just another talking point from the josef goebbles school of propaganda and obuscation.
george soros owned "j"udenrein streets director ben ami was filmed – and the video is on youtube – stating that the founding of the State of Israel was the "single greatest tragedy of the 20th century."
Please join our new page:) https://www.facebook.com/pages/People-of-the-world-oppose-Iran-to-become-nuclear/282331051871694?ref=hl
A page like that will sure force obama to initiate a DoJ investigation into your un-obama activities
As an American ex-Pat who has lived in Israel for 19 years, this whole thing scares me to death. My father fought for the U.S. Army in WWII, leaving his High School Graduation ceremony at Price Hill High School in Cincinnati and heading directly to the Recruitment Center with his friends to sign up voluntarily before he was drafted. He was sent home with his jaw shattered in half by shrapnel, along with a Bronze Star and Purple Heart. Our love for American was instilled early, and deeply, and I have NEVER found anything in the way of conflict by holding an additional citizenship to the State of Israel. If anything, living here and in the States has given me a deep appreciation for why the two countries are indeed so close. Our values are identical. Our morals are identical. Our tolerance for free speech is identical. Our free-market embrace for capitalism is identical.
All of the wonderful words coming out of the Obama administration mean nothing when compared to his actions. Senator Brown is part and parcel of the problem, which by the way was on full display at the beginning of the Democratic National Convention when they disgracefully shouted down the re-addition of "Jerusalem as Israel's Capital" (which had been removed), and was only re-added via the strident override of the L.A. Mayor who clearly did not receive a 2/3's vote in favor.
I was always proud of being a conservative Independent. However, the battle lines are so very stark and clear this election cycle, that I find myself for the first time definitively declaring Republican status.
Brown should be ashamed of himself. There's not a hole big enough for him to run and hide into.
Democrats and liberals are the most hate based and intolerant of all people. They hate competition. Yet, Jews will probably still vote for a dem.
Likewise so will some Christians continue to vote Demoncrat. But those who follow these demons these days…they have a lot of repenting to do because their party platform is Godless.
perhaps they are smarter than you!
Judy Shingler 95% of christian womem admit to using birth control and without these women you would not have much of a church!