web analytics
July 22, 2014 / 24 Tammuz, 5774
Israel at War: Operation Protective Edge
 
 
At a Glance
InDepth
Sponsored Post
IDC Advocacy Room IDC Fights War on Another Front

Student Union opens ‘hasbara’ room in effort to fill public diplomacy vacuum.



Home » InDepth » Op-Eds »

Nazi Epithet Removes Amos Oz From Israeli Discourse


Israeli author Amos Oz

Israeli author Amos Oz
Photo Credit: Tomer Neuberg /Flash 90

The true shame about Amos Oz’s epithet “neo-Nazi” to describe Israeli price-tag thugs is that the essence of his comments are important food for thought. But by choosing outrageous populist rhetoric over nuanced criticism, Oz essentially relegated his concerns to the wastebasket of history.

Before rejecting Oz’s comments, it is important to note that he could be an important social voice for Israelis of every stripe. His books, from My Michael to In the Land of Israel to A Tale of Love and Darkness reveal a passion for Israeli society, and for the Land of Israel, that few contemporary writers have managed to capture. Oz’s 1950s-era Jerusalem is a quiet border town where observant and secular Jews lived together as neighbors. His writing betrays a deep, emotional connection to the city, and to the Jerusalemites with whom he shared his adolescent years.

Oz’s relationship with Jewish tradition is less obvious, but a close reading of his work in Hebrew brings to mind another of Israel’s leading writers: Nobel laureate Shai Agnon. In contrast to Agnon, Oz’s work does not obviously draw on traditional sources or Jewish history. But he is clearly influenced by Agnon, and perhaps therefore by Agnon’s close relationship with Jewish sources. In short, it is simply impossible to dismiss Amos Oz as a “self-hating” Jew or Israeli.

All of which is what makes Oz’s absurd comparison of price tag vandals to European neo-Nazis so upsetting. Self-criticism is a sign of strength, not weakness, and many of Oz’s observations about the religious-Zionist world are deserving of consideration. Yes, many religious Zionist communities have failed to excise the price taggers from their midsts (public condemnations from religious Zionist leaders notwithstanding, does anyone doubt that price taggers would be awarded aliyot [Torah honors] at most synagogues in Judea and Samaria?). It is true that the price taggers enjoy a certain measure of backing, stated or implied, from rabbinic figures in Judea and Samaria and farther afield. Religious Zionist would do well to consider those facts.

Similarly, the need to denigrate Muslims or Christians in order to validate Judaism, settlement activity or our historic connection to the Land of Israel is a sad comment on the state of Torah Judaism. Is our belief in the Torah really that shaky that we feel a need to bring down other faiths, rather than rely on the validity of ours?

Our rights to and in the Land of Israel not dependent on rejecting other groups, and it does not do our community proud to be associated with pathetic grafitti. It is rightly a point of pride that Israel is a haven for religious freedom. It should go without saying that minority groups need not be made to feel subject to attack.

These criticisms are valid, or at least are important points for discussion, in our communities. Oz is correct to ask whether a Judaism that relies on insulting others is a Judaism we want to sustain.

But his use of the epithet “Nazi” effectively reduces his views to little more than the wild ranting of a hate-filled man. By equating graffiti on a mosque wall to the gas chambers for which real neo-Nazis clamor, Oz has taken himself out of the realm of legitimate social commentator. His comments are no longer astute, concerned observations about Israeli society, but rather venomous invective directed at a subset of that society that Oz has designated as “enemy.” If the settlement community are neo-Nazis, if Judea and Samaria Israelis – rather than the price tagging minority here – are the errant weed of Israeli society, it stands to reason there can be no compromise on the uprooting of their communities and of the total neutralization of their role in society.

About the Author: Avi is a news writer for The Jewish Press. In the past, he has covered Israel and the Jewish world for Israel National News, Ami magazine and other international media.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

Please use the Facebook Tab below to leave your comment:

35 Responses to “Nazi Epithet Removes Amos Oz From Israeli Discourse”

  1. No one who values decency and human rights and kindness should ever this this man’s name again.

  2. Martin Kool says:

    Sad and a sick mind

  3. David Bryan says:

    when spray paint is the same as gas chambers? Then I will listen. til then it’s crap.

  4. he should have weighted his words before uttering them. He did the same as Kerry using the words “Apartheid” and “intifada” at the worst possible time and in the silliest lashing out in frustration: he made himself irrelevant and that’s too bad.

  5. איש של מילים כתובות, שיואיל לסתום את הפה. יפה נפש במשמעות הערלה של המונח.

  6. If the IDF was liberating Judea and Samaria with places like Beth El, Shiloh and Hebron, no vandals would have to be doing the job clandestine.
    Israel, inherit the land that G-d gave to you!

  7. David Blatt says:

    Leave it to the Jewish Press to deflect the issues this good man raised

  8. He reminds of the soviet jews who formed Anti-zionist committee in USSR to prove their loyalty to the Communist Party, they also liked to use degrading epithets to describe Israeli Jews and Jews living USSR. and Jewish press is absolutely correct in its assessment.

  9. He reminds of the soviet jews who formed Anti-zionist committee in USSR to prove their loyalty to the Communist Party, they also liked to use degrading epithets to describe Israeli Jews and Jews living USSR. and Jewish press is absolutely correct in its assessment.

  10. Ben II says:

    who cares what some ridiculous lefty piece of garbage Oz has to say? Let him go join his buddies at Hamas or he can move to Syria.

  11. Dan Silagi says:

    Yes, Yigal Amir and Baruch Goldstein should be admired as the "heroes" they were. In what way were those two any better than Nazis, Wet Noodles?

  12. Judith Dowla says:

    International Court for this man rather like Judgement at Nurenburg would you imply he needs to be tried for international criminal acts.

  13. Jacky Horner says:

    And had he lived in Bar Kochba's time you might have suggested that he might have just prevented that stupid uprising against the great power of that time and prevented the Jews being slaughtered and booted out of our ancestral home for 2000 years.
    Also Rabbi there is very little different in the atrocious behaviour of the Tag Mechir hooligans and early Nazism

  14. We are supposed to the Chosen People and this obligates us to aspire to a higher standard. Unlike you, I live in Israel – in Samaria to be exact. Your comments imply that all Gentiles in Israel are guilty of raping, torturing and murdering Jews or pulling at their Payot are a misrepresentation of the truth. Terrorists and graffiti writers on both sides need to be brought to justice. Your comments are irresponsible and do not befit those of a Rabbi.

  15. Dan Silagi says:

    Judith Dowla The Third Reich is more "Rabbi" Friedman's speed.

  16. While I agree that Amos Oz's description is a gross exaggeration, I also believe that your attempt to underplay this as graffiti is equally irresponsible. These perpetrators of these disgraceful acts are racists and it is incumbent upon us to disassociate ourselves from their disgusting and completely unacceptable behavior.

  17. Dan Silagi says:

    He'll send his son in his place, Judy. Just like he did the last time.

  18. This is unadulterated garbage.

  19. Cody Flecker says:

    Judith Dowla Are you NUTS or something? Please read what you write and be more alert.

  20. David Blatt Thank you for letting us know where your allegiances lie. Amos Oz is not a good man. He’s the one deflecting the issues. Nothing more despicable than a self hating Jew (this might include you). His removal is well deserved and long overdue.

  21. Dan Silagi says:

    That's not correct. 4-D was for ordained ministers. There was a 2-D deferment for those studying to be ordained ministers. It was NOT for eternal students in Kollel or yeshiva. You had to get your smicha in a certain period of time, or in you went. Right into the infantry.

  22. Uzi Kattan says:

    Dan Silagi You are a leftist pig to call Rabbi Friedman a Nazi. Your comments are obscene but typical of leftists. You forget that Nazi means National SOCIALIST. The Torah obligates us to remove the non Jews from the Land if yo read Parashat Mattot, G-d tells us to remove the people there from the land so they don't commit terrorist atrocities against Jews. The ones who are calling to make parts of Israel Judenrein (free of Jews) are your ilk who want a terrorist state in the heart of Israel. It is NOT their land! G-d gave the land to His people and the Arabs can go to Arabia!

  23. Kjeld Hesselmann says:

    I think it’s timely to hold on to perspectives regarding who is intimidating who. In Israel and elsewhere Muslims disturb common order. And Israel holds a Muslim population over the critical level implying severe trouble in the land they inhabit. – In Europe it’s countries like France, UK, and Sweden, which are close to dangerous encounters with their Muslim “guests," the situation sharpens as in Judea and Samaria. With such guests, one needs only to hope for a genuine foe.

  24. Dan Silagi says:

    Didn't you just write that you want Israel to be goyimrein, hypocrite?

  25. When intellectuals go from 100 to zero. Amos should change his name to Amos Nozea

  26. And if the goyim follow the Word of Hashem? But are not converts? What then?

  27. Hashem helps those who help themselves. He who waits for Hashem to hand them salvation, will wait forever. But he who waits on Hashem, who serves him as a true servant, will be rewarded according to his faith. Bear this in mind, and ask for the right thing. It will be granted to you.

  28. Oz like all leftists is a hypocrite. He wouldn't dare call actual Muslim or Arab murderers and terrorists Neo Nazis instead he compares tire slashers and graffiti vandals to Nazis. He should be ashamed of himself for such a ridiculous comparison.

  29. When our own turn against us, adding themselves to the legions of Muslim and Arab terrorists, liars and libel spreaders, and the Europeans who hate Jews with so much passion – well then, they are best ignored in every sense. I will not be reading Amos Oz again, and am deeply saddened by his ill-thought comments directed at those who are simply sick and tired of being terrorised in their daily lives and wish – however ill-advisedly – to fight back.

  30. Dan Silagi May you and yours know only OSOH HAMACHALOW! Does your mother know you are an anti-Semite!? The Almighty tells us in Numbers 33,"If you do not evict the gentiles they shall be as thorns in your eyes and as pointed instruments in your sides." Shagatz Silagi do you have the same slurs against HaShem-Almighty? If you lived in the Chanukah era you would have been executed by the Macabbees, as they executed tens of thousand of Jewish traitors! To bad your parents did not abort you! Your parents should not have survived the Holocaust and instead other Jews been saved. Your simply a DRACK!!! Watch Judaism Wednesday bcat.tv 10:00Am and 6:00PM New York Time scroll down to Community media then click on Brooklyn Network then Click arrow in Channel 2

  31. Uzi Kattan says:

    Dan Silagi you are a sick Jew hater. Baruch Goldstein saved the Jews of Hevron from an Arab massacre and Yigal Amir was entrapped by the government to shoot Rabin who deserved it.

  32. Dan Silagi says:

    Uzi Kattan Baruch Goldstein was as much a Jewish "hero" as Osama Bin Laden was a Muslim hero. Unfortunately, there are many Muslims who regard Osama as a hero. Fortunately, there are only a tiny minority of Jewish *******s who regard Baruch Goldstein and Yigal Amir as such.

  33. Dan Silagi says:

    You can say this directly to my face, "Rabbi," right up close and personally. Name the time and place.

  34. it took you this long to recognize Amos Oz for a leftist idiot he is?

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Loading Facebook Comments ...
Loading Disqus Comments ...
Current Top Story
Netanyahu tries to bring UN's Ban down form the moon in Tel Aviv Tuesday.
UN’s Ban on the Moon with ‘Stop Fighting, Start Talking’ Message
Latest Indepth Stories
The Israel Test

Charges from the court of world public opinion and their refutations.

Military funeral in Israel

It is up to our government to ensure that their sacrifices were not made for short-term gains.

.

Supporting Israel, the only democracy in the Middle East, has become dangerous in Malmo.

Gaza

Proportionality Doctrine:The greater the military gain the greater the justifiable collateral damage

Regional pro-US Arab countries rely on Israel as a deterrence to rogue Islamic regimes.

He has always supported the underdog, once even quite literally, legislating a law that prohibits the abandonment of pets.

Temech is about providing a community – a place where religious women can learn, collaborate and refresh themselves with like-minded people.

Netanyahu has decided that the lives of Israeli are more important than looking good for Obama, U.N. and the NY Times.

Many Jews join the Israel-haters with their progressive ideology and politically correct obsessions.

“The will to triumph is a prerequisite for victory.” Abba Kovner

How can you run away from Israel and all the things that have shaped your life?

It’s as if Hamas has pulled a page out of Pharaoh’s handbook.

“Am HaNetzach Eino Mefached Mi Derech Aruka” (An eternal people doesn’t fear the long journey).

Isn’t it comforting to know that our God loves life, grants life, and promises eternal life?

With a loud and strong voice we must say “no” to individuals who take the law into their own hands.

More Articles from Avi Tuchmayer
Bat Ayin children with local Rabbi Natan Greenberg. Apparently the police feel their civil rights are negotiable

Presumably, Bat Ayin children suspected of price tag crimes, but no charges have been filed; several teens held for more than a week without seeing a lawyer

Former Australian Foreign Minister Bob Carr

Australia has always had a vocal far-left constituency, but they are a minority that have had little voice in mainstream politics. Is that changing?

From its inception in 1926, Tnuva has been a household name, for children as they learned to talk up through adulthood. How do you say “Tnuva” in Chinese?

The Palestinian Authority-run Ma’an news website is well known for promoting baseless Arab propaganda, but you’d have thought they could at least get their basic geography right. But in an article bemoaning the “nakba” – the “tragedy” of having lost a war they started – Ma’an seems to have forgotten some of the basic geography of […]

Political arrests continue unabated in both Ramallah and Gaza; Freedom Committee spokesman: Arrests have “strained reconciliation atmosphere.”

Police find three-meter tunnel in South Hebron Hills; last week, local communities ran dry thanks to hundreds of illegal taps into water main

There is lots of evidence that Hilary Rodham Clinton, the former senator from New York, first lady and secretary of state, will to try to win the Democratic nomination for president in 2016. Even before formally announcing her candidacy, she’s been campaigning and making waves, all in an attempt to keep her name not only […]

“I would prefer Abu Mazen to worry about making things better here than holding Nakba protests,” said one taxi driver.

    Latest Poll

    Israel's Iron Dome Anti-Missile System:





    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/indepth/opinions/nazi-epithet-removes-amos-oz-from-israeli-discourse/2014/05/11/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: