Photo Credit: Flash90

Since the post Talmudic era, it has been argued that it is no longer possible to ensure that people will be remembered simply by virtue of their teachings and good deeds. It was feared that with the increase of persecution, future exiles, and the spiritual decline of future generations, the Jewish people may indeed forget the earlier generations. As a result, a more permissive attitude toward erecting elaborate monuments has prevailed. So too, the negative attitude toward monuments never extended to the style of tombstones or grave markings that are customarily used today. Even according to the more permissive view, however, a monument should only be erected upon a grave and not at other venues. According to this approach, monuments should not be erected in public places in memory of victims of the Holocaust, and the like1 though some authorities permit even such monuments.2

A sad situation was once brought to the attention of Rav David Tzvi Hoffman by a man whose son had died during the course of a long sea voyage. Due to a lack of space on the ship to properly store the body, the crew threw it overboard. The father asked Rav Hoffman his opinion about erecting a monument for his son in the local Jewish cemetery even though there would be no grave beneath it. Rav Hoffman replied that although there is no inherent prohibition in doing so, it would be of more benefit to the soul of the deceased if charity were to be distributed in his memory, particularly to an institution of Torah study, rather than erecting a monument.

Advertisement


There are different customs as to what should be written on a tombstone. Although the name of the deceased should certainly appear on the tombstone, this was not always done.3 For example, there was once a custom in the city of Chevron not to inscribe any names on a tombstone. Widespread Sephardic custom is to list the name of the deceased along with the name of his or her mother.4 This is closely related to the custom of using the mother’s name when praying for one who is ill.5 Furthermore, we find numerous examples throughout Scripture where people are referred to in connection with their mother when discussing spiritual matters.6 We also find this idea in the Talmud where we are told that when praying for the health of another person, we should mention the person’s name followed by the name of his or her mother.7 So too, it is noted that it is always certain who a person’s mother is (as there is always a “witness” at birth) though it is not always certain who a person’s father is (at least it wasn’t in ancient times). Most Ashkenazim, however, list the name of the deceased along with the name of his or her father,8 though some will also mention the name of the mother somewhere on the tombstone,9 as was done on the tombstone of Rav Pinchas Hirschprung.

The date of death should also be included on a tombstone. The letters “tav, nun, tzadi, bet, hei,” an acronym for “Tehei Nishmato Tzrura B’tzror Hachaim” (May his/her soul be bound in the bond of life), should appear on the tombstone and it is usually the last thing written on the tombstone.10 Although there is some opposition to including English (or other languages) along with secular names and dates on tombstones,11 common custom is to allow it considering that so many people are unable to read or understand a tombstone written in Hebrew. So too, one might want to consider having Hebrew on one side and English (or other language) on the other side, as is the case on the tombstone of Rav David Tzvi Hoffman. There is also a custom to include the name of the deceased’s rabbis and teachers on a tombstone.12

One should limit the extent of praise for the deceased on a tombstone.13 As mentioned, a tombstone should not be overly elaborate or distinctly more expensive than the average tombstone.14 It is forbidden to engrave a picture of the deceased onto a tombstone. Besides the fact that it is of non-Jewish origin to do so, it would be forbidden to pray in front of such a grave, as one may not pray facing an image.15 All the tombstones in a cemetery should be designed and arranged the same way for every person. One is permitted to prepare one’s burial spot,16 tombstone,17 and shrouds18 in one’s lifetime.

One may use one tombstone for two people. In such a situation, the tombstone should be double the size or placed in between the two graves.19 In some communities, the custom is to erect a tombstone in a horizontal manner in which the stone covers the entire surface of the grave, and this is quite widespread in Israel. In most other communities, the tombstone is placed upright either at the head or the foot of the deceased, though the former is to be preferred.20 A tombstone is not erected for a child who died less than thirty days old, though the spot should be clearly marked as a grave.21

The Jewish way of showing honor to the dead when visiting a grave is to place a small stone upon their tombstone.22 It is explained that doing so honors the deceased by letting others know that the grave has been visited.23 One should also place one’s left hand upon the tombstone for a few moments when visiting a grave.24 It is forbidden to sit or even lean on a tombstone.25

______________________

  1. Minchat Yitzchak 1:29.
  2. Marchei Lev (Tzirelson) 42.
  3. Moshav Zkeinim M’baalei Hatosfot, Parshat Shemot, s.v. “V’ela shemot”; Mekor Chessed to Sefer Chassidim 738. Note: Names may not have always been written on Jewish tombstones. See Meshivat Nefesh, YD 17 cited in Nitei Gavriel, Aveilut, 66:5.
  4. Gesher Hachaim 28:3.
  5. See Panim Yafot, Beha’alotcha, cited in Piskei Teshuvot 116:2.
  6. Tehillim 86:16.
  7. Rashi, Shabbat 66b; also in Berachot 55b according to the Ein Yaakov version.
  8. Gesher Hachaim 2:24:2.
  9. B’tzel Hachochma 3:91.
  10. Maharam Schik, YD 171; Pnei Baruch 36:6.
  11. Maharam Schik, YD 171; Shaarei Tzedek 199; Get Pashut, EH 126; Pri Hasadeh 1:3; Yafeh L’lev 4:178.
  12. Shaarei Halacha U’minhag, YD p. 368.
  13. Chaim Sha’al 71:6; Chochmat Adam 155:6; Divrei Malkiel 5:257.
  14. Beit Shlomo, YD 2:226.
  15. Chatam Sofer 6:4; Maharam Shik, YD 171; Mateh Levi (Horovitz) 68; Mishmeret Shalom 40:83.
  16. Yaskil Avdi Y.D. 8:32.
  17. B’tzel Hachachma 4:31, Sheilat Yitzchak 3:96.
  18. Aruch Hashulchan, YD 339:5
  19. Levushei Mordechai, YD 53; Chazon Nachum 116; Mei Yehuda, YD 105; Yagel Yakov, OC 11; B’tzel Hachochma 4:31.
  20. Chavatzelet Hasharon, YD 1:94; B’tzel Hachochma 5:151; Darkei Chaim 35:5; Zecher Simcha 233.
  21. Gesher Hachaim 28:3.
  22. Be’er Heitiv, OC 224:8; Kaf Hachaim, OC 581:92; Pnei Baruch 37:21; Darkei David, YD 15. According to Yitzchak Yeranein, YD 3:2 the custom originates in the Mishna (Eduyot 5:6), which states that a stone would be placed on a coffin in order to atone for sins whose penalty was stoning. Others disagree. See Rivevot Ephraim 8:51.
  23. Be’er Heitev, OC 224:8; Eliya Rabba 224:7. See also Taamei Haminhagim 1069
  24. Be’er Heitev, OC 224:8; Kitzur Shulchan Aruch 128:13. See Shekalim 1:1
  25. Tur, YD 364; Taz, YD 364:1; Shach, YD 364:3. Regarding walking over a grave see: Taz, YD 364:1 and Korban Netanel, Ta’anit 2:3.
Advertisement
SHARE
Previous articleMusic, Monologues, and Mikva Memories: More than Entertainment
Next articleNorth Korea Fires Suspected ICBM in Second Day of Missile Fire
Rabbi Ari Enkin
Rabbi Ari Enkin, a resident of Ramat Beit Shemesh, is a researcher and writer of contemporary halachic issues. He teaches halacha, including semicha, one-on-one to people all over the world, online. He is also the author of the “Dalet Amot of Halacha” series (9 volumes), the rabbinic director of United with Israel, and a rebbe at a number of yeshivot and seminaries. Questions and feedback are welcomed: [email protected].