web analytics
July 5, 2015 / 18 Tammuz, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post


Authority, Shmothority, Is Hebrew National Meat Kosher?

One judge wondered how meat could be considered kosher, if the employees of the kosher slaughtering firm "just passed on the cows."
shocked cow

A Minnesota court is hearing an appeal of a lawsuit arguing that Hebrew National is falsely labeling its products as “100 percent kosher.”

The original lawsuit, filed in May 2012 by 11 plaintiffs claiming fraud and breach of contract, was dismissed in January by U.S. District Court Judge Donovan Frank on the grounds that the issue is religious in nature and therefore not for the courts to decide.

The appeal of the case, Wallace et al v. ConAgra Foods Inc., was heard in St. Paul on Dec. 19 before a three-judge panel of the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals.

According to the plaintiffs’ brief, ex-employees of AER Services, which did the slaughtering for Hebrew National, testified that they were pressured to certify as kosher at least 70 percent of the beef they slaughtered, according to the American Jewish World, the Minnesota newspaper that broke the original story.

The plaintiffs contend that the U.S. court does not have to resolve any Judaic religious issue, because ConAgra employed a production quota system, where a predetermined percentage of cows would be labeled as kosher.

Anne Regan, attorney for the plaintiffs, told the panel of judges that ConAgra was well aware of the problems with AER, and with Triangle K, the firm that provided the hechsher, or kosher certification, for the meat. She reiterated the argument that the quota undermined ConAgra’s claim that it was producing kosher meat to the highest standards.

Judge James B. Loken pressed his question about what makes meat kosher or not, and suggested that if an animal “wasn’t well enough” to meet a “rabbi’s standard, you can’t go there.” In other words, the U.S. court can’t sort out what constitutes a kosher product.

Regan said that if the case was sent back to the district court, attorneys for the plaintiffs could file discovery motions and try to prove that ConAgra was defrauding consumers. The plaintiffs’ brief noted that consumers view kosher food as the “new organic.”

Judge William Jay Riley, chief judge of the 8th Circuit court, also expressed skepticism about how meat could be considered kosher, if the employees of the kosher slaughtering firm “just passed on the cows.”

AER Services, ConAgra and Triangle K have denied the allegations and blamed disgruntled former employees for trying to sully Hebrew National’s reputation. Their attorneys reiterated their argument that a U.S. court cannot constitute what qualifies as kosher, the American Jewish World reported.

“A secular court simply cannot second guess a religious determination by a religious authority,” said Corey Gordon, representing the defendants.

The judges said they would rule on the appeal “as soon as possible,” the paper said.

JTA and AJWNews content was used in this report.

About the Author:


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

12 Responses to “Authority, Shmothority, Is Hebrew National Meat Kosher?”

  1. Our fellow frum sisters and brothers were right. You can’t trust all hechsher symbols. Yikes.

  2. Gil Gilman says:

    Gag me with a spoon. It will be sinai kosher from now on for me and mine, oh wait, they quit! Any ideas?

  3. Sara Mandell says:

    I think it is impossible to know what percentage of a group of cattle will or won't be kosher. I read in a journal several years ago that at least 11% do not meet kosher standards and are sold for less money to non-kosher butchers for less money. To make the shochet "pass it on" is to destroy the trust one would have about ANY kosher meat. It makes a joke of our G-d given law & puts economics before G-d's Law. Isn't that idol worship. Stick to the Torah law & G-d will make sure your economics won't be a problem.

  4. Dont care . Love it !

  5. Anonymous says:

    Isn't it better to show respect for all Robonim until one know for SURE that there is a problem? Isn't that at the core of what the Chofetz Chaim teaches as Loshen Hora. Better to not say anything. No one has ever been found guilty of eating UNkosher by following a Rabbi who said it was kosher. However, many have committed acts of baseless hatred by following the gossip of the man sitting next to him or the unsubstantiated claims reported in a court, a Beis Din, or a newspaper. I would rather eat a kosher pig (chas v'shalom) then say something bad about a fellow Jew or Rabbi that I don't know.

  6. Ita Benjamin says:

    US courts are right that it’s not their place to determine whether or not standards of kashrut were met. As long Triangle-K didn’t take any action against them for kashrut violations, ConAgra isn’t violating any laws with a marketing slogan. The certifying organization is responsible for overseeing kashrut; that’s why ConAgra pays them! Now, if Triangle K wasn’t aware of what was happening or there were some violation of their contract, they would have a case against the processor and possibly then the religious kosher consumer as well.

  7. Corey Gordon says:

    Please note that the plaintiffs sued only ConAgra, which I represent. There are no other defendants nor do I represent Triangle K, AER, or AFG.

  8. Anonymous says:

    Even though the cow may pass initial inspection as a 100% 'acceptable' kosher animal, it does not mean that by the end of the processing it meets acceptable kosher standard. Acceptable standards are according to Torah Halachak . For example, a plant that produces kosher meat on Shabbos is NOT KOSHER.etc…

  9. Anonymous says:

    When meat is selected, shechteted slaughtered) and prepared in an halachically approprieate way, it contains spiritual sparks of Holiness that a Jewish soul (neshama) can ignite. Kosher food is food for the Body and Soul of a Jewish person.
    writenut

  10. Anonymous says:

    The core question is under what circumstances do we want secular courts to decide issues that are normally decided by Rabeim? I'm not saying that there are none. For example, I think it's good to have laws to require giving a Get along with a civil divorce. But we all have the ability to ask our own rabbi whether to trust the triangle K.

  11. Oy. It’s either kasher or it isn’t. There is no inbetween on this.

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
Secretary of State Hillary Clinton with Prime Minister Netanyahu in 2012.
Hillary Clinton Says She Will Be Better Friend than Obama to Israel
Latest News Stories
Zarif and Kerry on the Fourth of July.

Kerry spent the Fourth of July talking with his Iranian counterpart, Mohammad Javad Zarif.

Placard at counter protest of neo-Nazis in London on Saturday.

Thirty Policemen escorted a total of 21 neo-Nazi in the “anti-Jewification” protest that flopped.

Young teenagers point rifles at Syrian soldiers at ancient Roman amphitheater.

ISIS released a video of a modern-day replay of the thirst for blood in ancient Roman amphitheaters.

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton with Prime Minister Netanyahu in 2012.

The woman who once kissed Suha Arafat has a different attitude when it comes to funding her campaign for president.

A third Grad rocket was found in the Eshkol region on Saturday.

If Lapid decides that his party will support the proposal in the Knesset, he will go down in history as the man who saved Israel’s gas industry and credibility.

The House of Bishops, led by Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori, overwhelmingly defeated the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions resolution.

US alone voted no on UNHRC Resolution condemning only Israel for wrongdoing in last summer’s conflict.

Sinai terrorists expanded their range of attack Friday, aiming rocket fire at southern Israel as well.

5:21 PM The rocket landed in a field in the Eshkol region. Apparently from Sinai. 5:06 PM Channel 1 reports that citizens say they saw the rocket fly over from Sinai. 4:49 PM IDF Spox says they believe only 1 rocket was launched. The IDF is examining if the rocket was launched from the Sinai. […]

Iran is not budging in nuclear talks on its refusal to allow spot inspections of military sites.

Nothing like a Kosher frank for the 4th of July, even if this year, you have to cook it before Shabbat.

Nothing quite like Hamas terrorist supporters on the Temple Mount openly waving their flags..

Machsom Watch women came to harass IDF soldiers in Hebron but embarrassed themselves instead.

A Palestinian Authority Arab was shot and killed after he attacked an Israeli army commander driving in near Jerusalem.

The US Mennonite church votes to table an anti-Israel BDS resolution for two years.

More Articles from Jewish Press Staff
Nicholas Winton with one of the Jewish children he rescued.

Nicholas Winton saved hundreds of Jewish children from the gas chambers but said nothing for nearly 50 years.

Four Israelis hurt Monday night in a driveby terror attack by terrorists near Shvut Rachel.

Perhaps on a deeper level, the mitzvah of parah adumah at this junction was not just to purify the body, but the spirit as well.

A Smartphone app may be able to help prevent Parkinson’s disease patients from falling.

A shooting victim in Wadi Joz traveled for treatment all the way to Hadassah Hospital in Jerusalem.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/breaking-news/authority-shmothority-is-hebrew-national-meat-kosher/2013/12/24/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: