web analytics
July 28, 2015 / 12 Av, 5775
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post


Academic Group Hosts BDS, Bars Pro-Israel Groups at Panel on Israel

The Modern Language Association does not want to listen to pro-Israel language at a discussion on academic boycotts.
Despite a big win, there are still groups supporting BDS

Despite a big win, there are still groups supporting BDS

The pro-Israel campus groups Hillel International and the Israel on Campus Coalition (ICC) have been denied the right to present a discussion on Israel at the Jan. 9-12 Modern Language Association (MLA) convention in Chicago, JNS.org has learned.

MLA’s convention includes a roundtable discussion that will feature supporters but no opponents of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel.

The discussion – titled “Academic Boycotts: A Conversation about Israel and Palestine “– is seen as a possible precursor to an MLA academic boycott of Israel, which would mirror recent boycotts by the American Studies Association and the Native American and Indigenous Studies Association.

The MLA convention will consider a resolution that condemns Israel for alleged “arbitrary denials of entry to Gaza and the West Bank by U.S. academics who have been invited to teach, confer, or do research at Palestinian universities.”

Hillel and the ICC asked the 30,000-member MLA for the chance to present what they called an “open discussion featuring MLA members regarding academic freedom in Israel, its territories, and Gaza,” but MLA said the deadline to book a meeting at the convention had passed.

“The MLA convention has procedures for its members to organize sessions, and that deadline was 1 April [2013],” MLA Executive Director Rosemary G. Feal, the MLA’s executive director, wrote in an email to ICC Executive Director Jacob Baime. “We do not rent space at our convention for nonmembers to hold discussions.”

The existing MLA session’s speakers will include BDS movement co-founder Omar Barghouti; University of Texas professor Barbara Jane Harlow, who has stated her support for the ASA boycott of Israel; University of Southern California professor of English David Lloyd, a well-known BDS activist; and Wesleyan University professor Richard Ohmann, who signed a 2009 letter that described Israeli treatment of Palestinians as “one of the most massive, ethnocidal atrocities of modern times.” University of Texas professor Samer M. Ali, who publicly defended the ASA boycott, organized the roundtable.

“We believe the members of the MLA deserve to hear a far more diverse set of perspectives on the issue of academic freedom in Israel and nearby countries. The MLA members, as academics, certainly can appreciate the value of multiple perspectives on what is a very controversial issue,” ICC’s Baime said.

ICC and Hillel said they are now considering organizing a “balancing panel” discussion at a nearby location during the MLA convention. The panel would feature MLA members who oppose the anti-Israel resolution being considered at the convention.

Ali, the organizer of the convention’s roundtable on BDS, told The Chronicle of Higher Education that the roundtable assumes that Israel violates the rights of Palestinians, and that the debate will center on what to do about it.

“If people want to come and debate occupation, I think it will be a waste of their time, because that’s not what the roundtable is about,” Ali said.

About the Author: www.JNS.org is an independent, non-profit business resource and wire service covering Jewish news and Israel news for Jewish media throughout the English-speaking world.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

11 Responses to “Academic Group Hosts BDS, Bars Pro-Israel Groups at Panel on Israel”

  1. Oh, excuse me MLA,BDS. Go to Hell. Oh, sorry. Your’re already there.

  2. They must be too academic to have any common sense. They live in their own world, not anything that corresponds to reality.

  3. Gil Gilman says:

    I have a great number of linguistic books on my shelves that they can burn when they get that far. I'm downsizing my library, now that I discovered it will all fit on my iPad. My books in Hebrew have tainted the entire collection for them, I'm sure.

  4. Jews should not contribute to any University which discriminates against Jews and Israel. Hit them in the pocket it always works.
    Holocaust survivor.

  5. Edward Lobel says:

    Gil, you should NEVER burn a book for any reason!
    If you have no use for a book, give it away to another person or a library.

  6. Gil Gilman says:

    I'm afraid you missed the irony of my statement. I have already donated numerous books to the JCC worth hundreds of dollars. Why would I burn a book? You really caught me on the wrong day with that comment. I've been in constant pain with no sleep and have no tolerance for that nonsense. If you know me so little as that don't bother.

  7. Ltc Howard says:

    The modern language Association has converted an academic meeting (normally tax deductible) into a political meeting (definitely not tax-deductible).

    Meeting attendance lists should be easily attainable.

    Maybe it would be a good idea to file a letter of protest naming each attendee and challenging the deduction they might claim on their income tax return for attending this meeting.

  8. Anonymous says:

    O for Pete sakes — you get on the MLA platform by proposing a panel, and you don't get on it by not being a member, not proposing a panel, and deciding that you don't like a panel that has been accepted.

    Making a demand in violation of the organizations rules is not being "barred" or "censored." Supporters of Israel should go to the session and argue against a boycott, and organize their own panel at the 2015 MLA.

    I'll rejoin the stupid organization just to vote against a boycott if it comes up, though I'm against the current Israeli government. Academic boycotts are ridiculous.

  9. The Jews ethnic cleansing of Palestinians and the slaughter of untold millions can not go unpunished. The number of Palestinians slaughtered by the Jews dwarfs the mere three million Bengalis killed by the pakistanis or the three to 4 million sunnis exiled from Iraq. The Israelis have a racist policy calling for a Jewish state as a rebellion against the legitimate and freedom loving Islamic states throughout the middle east. Allowing the state of Israel to exist will allow for westyern enlightenment thinking and homosexuality to proliferate. All MLA professors should boycott Israeli academics due to the obvious ungodly thoughts of the Jewish professors, who should be stoned to death. That is why no Jews will be allowed to live in Palestine, and all American professors should boycott Israeli institutions until they give up their godless enlightenment beliefs. Allah Akbar.

  10. …think with an open mind,love with an open hand…

Comments are closed.

Current Top Story
MEMRI clip showing a passerby scolding the sheik for teaching martyrdom to children at Al-Aqsa Mosque summer camp. Translated by MEMRI.
Jerusalem Arab Children Taught ‘Martyrdom’ at Al Aqsa Mosque Summer Camp
Latest News Stories
MEMRI clip showing a passerby scolding the sheik for teaching martyrdom to children at Al-Aqsa Mosque summer camp. Translated by MEMRI.

Arab children are taught to be “martyrs” at the Al Aqsa Mosque summer camp in Jerusalem.

Rabbi Yehuda Glick, founder and head of the Temple Mount Heritage Foundation

Temple Mount activist Yehuda Glick praises Israel’s government but says “more” needs to be done about disparity at the site.

Beit El. early Tuesday morning, July 28, 2015

The scenes from last night and today in Beit El are eerily reminiscent of the scenes from Gush Katif 10 years ago, the above photo in particular.

Military officials called this a most serious incident, but stressed that the soldiers fled the outpost while the battalion and their fellow fighters were not on operational duty.

Gaddafi wasn’t in the court, as he is currently being held captive by one of the former rebel groups in Zintan.

Britain issues alert for its citizens against travel to Turkey due to “high” threat of terror attacks by ISIS.

The marijuana valued at $50 million, and seized in an operation over the past few months.

Nuttall told an undercover policeman that his wife believed she should send Jewish children to paradise, since “grown-up Jews” go to “eternal hell.”

Local Israel Police have arrested seven Jerusalem Arabs in connection with recent attacks on Jews.

Half of all Israeli Arab MKs ascended the Temple Mount to protest “police brutality,” expelling Jews along the way.

The Temple Mount movement strongly condemns Tuesday’s visit by Israeli Arab MKs to the ancient site.

The police acted out of “zero tolerance.” Arabs screaming “slaughter Jews” were not arrested.

The Secretary is visiting Egypt, but stopping off in Israel would only give ammunition to Congressmen opposing the nuclear deal with Iran.

The remand of three other suspects has been extended and the Attorney General’s office announced that it would file an indictment against two of them.

Both civilian and military assistance is being delayed, and Hamas is having a tough time dealing with it.

Rumsfeld tweeted on Monday: “Releasing spy Jonathan Pollard doesn’t make the #IranDeal any less of a disaster for Israel & the free world.”

More Articles from JNS News Service
The Beavers family of Columbus, Ohio, among the 221 new immigrants to Israel aboard the 53rd Nefesh B'Nefesh charter aliyah flight.

Aaron is a plumber, Tracie, a former National Guard member, wants to volunteer in the IDF.

Father Gabriel Naddaf holds the Christian Empowerment Council new anti-BDS guide.

The organization also is encouraging young Christians to serve in the IDF.

The IDF has decided to implement a new practice to improve the security of hitchhikers in Judea and Samaria — one year after three hitchhiking Israeli teens were abducted and murdered. Yisrael HaYom reported that the IDF will be sending reservists in civilian vehicles to provide security for hitchhikers in the territories. The cars will […]

The California State Assembly on Monday passed a resolution urging action on the increasingly rampant anti-Semitism on University of California (UC) campuses. The resolution urges each UC campus to “adopt a resolution condemning all forms of anti-Semitism and racism.” The bipartisan measure was introduced by State Senator Jeff Stone (R-Riverside County) follow-ing a series of […]

Sagi Muki defeated his opponent from Georgia.

New York follows Indiana, Illinois and Tennessee to condemn BDS.

The course was cancelled because of lack of interest.

All you need is a few days vacation and a few thousand dollars to show the Israeli flag at the big game.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/academic-group-hosts-bds-bars-pro-israel-groups-at-panel-on-israel/2014/01/02/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: