Photo Credit: Jewish Press

Untimely News
‘…We Deduce That A Mourner Is Forbidden To Wear Shoes…’
(Mo’ed Katan 20b)



The Gemara relates that when R. Chiya, who lived in Eretz Yisrael, was belatedly informed of the death of his brother and sister in Babylonia, he instructed a servant to remove his shoes as a sign of mourning and then to escort him to the bathhouse. The Gemara deduces three halachot from this incident:

  1. a) The halacha follows Rabbi Akiva (20a), who asserts that upon hearing a shemua rechoka (belated report) of the death of one’s relative, one is obligated to observe only one day of mourning. [Belated in this context means more than 30 days after the death.]
  2. b) An avel (a mourner) is forbidden to wear shoes.
  3. c) We apply the concept of miktzas hayom ke’kulo – a small portion of the day is considered like an entire day – and the mourner is only obligated to observe the laws of mourning for a portion of the day, not for the entire day. Therefore, it was sufficient for R. Chiya to remove his shoes for a few moments and bathe immediately afterwards.

Not In The Mishna

The Keren Orah (Mo’ed Katan ad loc.) comments that the law requiring a mourner to remove his shoes was apparently not well known, for it is not mentioned in the Mishna. Even though the baraitha (21a) lists washing among the acts prohibited during shiva (the seven days of mourning) – as some of the prohibitions listed by the baraitha are subject to dispute – the Gemara found it necessary to derive from R. Chiya’s incident that a mourner may not bathe.

A Different Chiddush

Ramban (Tovas Ha’adam, Chavel ed. P. 237; see Y.D. 402:2) maintains that the fact that an avel may not bathe is well known (see Mo’ed Katan 15b, stating that a mourner is prohibited to don leather shoes), and the chiddush (novelty) derived from R. Chiya’s conduct pertains to the laws of shemua rechoka. The Gemara infers from R. Chiya’s conduct that the removal of one’s shoes for a few moments is a sufficient demonstration of mourning in cases of a belated report, and one need not observe the other mourning rites, such as atifas harosh (wrapping the head) and kefiyas hamitah (overturning the bed or sitting on the floor). However, according to Ramban, if one is engaged in any of those private activities forbidden to a mourner at the time of notification, he is to immediately cease that activity. [Keren Orah infers from the wording of Mishneh Torah (Hilchos Avel 7:2) that Rambam is of the opinion that upon hearing a shemua rechoka one is obligated to observe all the rites of mourning, not just the removal of one’s shoes.]


Previous articleDC Police Arrest Suspect in Union Station Swastika Graffiti
Next article3rd Shooting Attack in the Shomron in One Week
Rabbi Yaakov Klass is Rav of K’hal Bnei Matisyahu in Flatbush; Torah Editor of The Jewish Press; and Presidium Chairman, Rabbinical Alliance of America/Igud HaRabbonim.