We all make choices. In doing so, we are essentially making judgments about issues. And when we make judgments about issues, it is not always easy to avoid the trap of making judgments about those who choose a different way.
Yet avoid that trap we must, for the sake of Jewish unity. We are commanded to rise above such petty judgments and to judge only ourselves.
So it is for me with tekhelet, the sky blue color that men are commanded by the Torah to wear in their ritual fringes alongside the white. I am speaking of myself here. While many of my neighbors are focused on embracing the wearing of the blue, I find myself conflicted about the energy invested in the practice. And while tekhelet is a biblical commandment, it’s one full of “buts” that bring me up short.
For instance: Jewish men are commanded to wear tekhelet but, as a people, we lost the mesora, the chain of custody that would empirically tell us which blue is THAT blue. We know that the source of tekhelet was a snail, but we don’t know for sure which snail is the right one.
In my capacity as a writer at Kars4Kids, I went to an all-day conference on the subject, 100 Years to Tekhelet Research, and heard from experts in many related disciplines and learned a great deal, but I came out of the conference feeling much the same as I did going in: the evidence is not absolute and therefore inconclusive.
That said, the search for tekhelet is a fascinating subject and the endeavor is rooted in Torah.
As usual, Finn Partners did a bang-up job organizing the event, and there were some mighty important people there: former chancellor of Yeshiva University Rabbi Dr. Norman Lamm, Israeli Supreme Court Judge Neal Hendel, and MK Isaac Herzog, whose grandfather, Chief Ashkenazi Rabbi Yitzchak Halevi Herzog (zatzal), wrote a dissertation on the subject of tekhelet in 1913 as a seminal figure in the search for “himmel blau.” I spoke with Dr. Ari Greenspan, my across-the-street neighbor and a founder of Ptil Tekhelet.
V: In his talk, Rav Weinreb of the OU touched a bit on the Haredi reluctance to accept tekhelet. Several people at the conference have told me that Rav Chaim Pinchas Scheinberg (zatzal), who was known to wear many types of tzitzit at once to cover all Halachic bases, wore your tekhelet. Who else from the Haredi community was/is known to wear tekhelet?
Ari Greenspan: There’s Rav Zalman Nechemia Goldberg who has actually served as a posek. There’s Rav Amram Opman who is one of the judges of the Beit Din of the Badatz Eida Haredis and Rav Dichovsky on the Bet Din HaGadol of the Rabbanut. The entire Zilberman clan wears tekhelet. And the truth is, as you begin to go into the Haredi world, you begin to find some of the unique, individual thinkers that are looking for truth, and wearing it. Not a lot, but a significant number of Haredim. In the English world, both Rabbi Herschel Shachter and Rabbi Yisroel Belsky of the OU.
V: Well, but those last two—they aren’t Haredi.
Ari Greenspan: They’re American Haredim. Belsky’s a big name!
V: No one can say for sure if this is really the tekhelet, right?
Ari Greenspan: Here’s what I’ll tell you. There is no doubt that this is the color that our ancestors wore. There is no doubt that this is the source that the Romans used—no other source. And there’s no doubt that it was this snail—that the Romans killed people for wearing the color of this snail. There’s also no doubt that there was no other snail that the Romans used and we know for a fact that what we wore is what the Romans wore.
About the Author: Blogger and mother of 12 Varda Meyers Epstein is a third-generation Pittsburgher who made aliyah at age 18 and never looked back. A proud settler who lives in the biblical Judean heartland, Varda serves as the communications writer for the nonprofit car donation program, Kars for Kids.
If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.
Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.
If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.