web analytics
December 25, 2014 / 3 Tevet, 5775
 
At a Glance
News & Views
Sponsored Post
8000 meals Celebrate Eight Days of Chanukah – With 8,000 Free Meals Daily to Israel’s Poor

Join Meir Panim’s campaign to “light up” Chanukah for families in need.



'HOLY PLASTIC!'

‘Plastic Bag’ Airplane Passenger a Kohen Staying Pure?

Look up in the sky? Is It a bird? Is it a plane? No, it’s Plastic Man – the Orthodox Jew who wrapped himself in plastic on an airplane, apparently because he is a very scrupulous Kohen.
plastic-man-on-airplane

An Orthodox Jewish man, wrapped in a plastic bag in his airline seat, apparently did so because he was probably a Kohen who went to extreme lengths to make sure he would not be ritually impure if the plane flew over a Jewish cemetery.

Kohenim are prohibited from coming into contact with dead bodies, and many rabbis have taken the strict opinion that a Kohen may not ride in a plane if he knows ahead of time that it will fly directly over a Jewish cemetery. Many have ruled that if does not know of the flight plan, he may ride in the airplane.

El Al once agreed to change a fight trajectory to avoid flying over a cemetery.

The man wrapped in plastic, whose photograph first appeared on the Redditor site and later on the Gothamist site, apparently did not want to take any chances. By covering himself in plastic, he established a separation between him and impurities.

However, since he arrived at his destination safe and sound, it can be assumed there was a hole in the plastic bag so he could breathe.

Some readers of Redditor suggested that “plastic man” was making sure he would not come into contact with the woman sitting behind him, but that is doubtful since it is unlikely he carried a plastic covering “just in case.”

Or maybe he simply wanted some attention.

About the Author: Tzvi Ben Gedalyahu is a graduate in journalism and economics from The George Washington University. He has worked as a cub reporter in rural Virginia and as senior copy editor for major Canadian metropolitan dailies. Tzvi wrote for Arutz Sheva for several years before joining the Jewish Press.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

27 Responses to “‘Plastic Bag’ Airplane Passenger a Kohen Staying Pure?”

  1. Lisa Liel says:

    See, and I thought it was a life-sized Hassid doll.

  2. Lisa Liel says:

    See, and I thought it was a life-sized Hassid doll.

  3. Josh Backon says:

    But these are gentile cemetaries ! See Yoreh Deah Siman 372 and Chelkat Yaakov I Siman 26 based on the Shach YD 372 s"k bet. Also Iggrot Moshe YD II 166. There is a klal: safek tumah bi'reshut ha'rabbim mutar. And here we're dealing with a POSSIBLE flight over a gentile cemetary. And even with a Jewish cemetary it's an issur d'rabbanan. The chilul hashem these idiots caused is much greater.

  4. Daniel Rosen says:

    If the insight in the article is based on a "probably" then how is this news? Does the writer know the facts of the story? The provenance of the picture? Has he interviewed those involved? Why is this a news story if it is conjecture? Is the article about religious experts who have issued rulings condoning or dondemning it? Is it an expose about the practices of El Al? I wouldn't know — I don't know what airline the guy in the picture is flying. Guess work is not journalism.

  5. Yehudis Gross says:

    How does he breathe?

  6. Raizy Fogel says:

    sorry, the picture doesn't look real, looks like a computer trick… stupid!

  7. Debbie Lee Burton says:

    I'm thinking about all those plastic bags that have warnings about keeping them away from children who might put it over their head and suffocate themselves. Now large bags will have to add warnings about adult Chasidim using them this way. I wonder how long a person can be in a bag before it is a health risk.

  8. Peter W. Singer says:

    This is what I would call a schmuck.

  9. Peter W. Singer says:

    This is what I would call a schmuck.

  10. Peter W. Singer says:

    This is what I would call a schmuck.

  11. Peter W. Singer says:

    Looks to me like a used body bag from the morgue.

  12. Kent Persson says:

    The fuselage of the aircraft ought to provide far better shielding agains Jewish cemeteries than a plastic bag with air holes.

  13. Yehuda Cohen says:

    Maybe there was a dead body on the plane. I have seen a casket put in first class and not in the bagage area. Only the family of that person sat in first class. More needs to be investigated and reported on this matter and not leave it to guess work as Daniel Rosen has stated otherwise an article like this opens people's mouths to Lashon Harah.

  14. Josh- go learn what "Hillul Hashem" is and what it is not. When it is an actual sin then it is a Hillul Hashem, when their is no sin it is not a Hillul Hashem. You also need to see how to talk about others and perhaps you need to make repentance in that regards before pointing the finger.

  15. Anonymous says:

    Has the "reporter" verified this story. The picture looks photo-shopped to me.

  16. The airplane should be adequate protection for the Kohen (i.e., the Rambam/Ramban was wrong and so are the poskim following him). The theory being followed by the poskim is that there is a form of contamination emitting from dead people that issues straight up into the sky. Apparently, one solution put forth is that concrete siding and a concrete lid can block this "contamination" from affecting the Kohen's ritual purity. When the Rambam thought of a vehicle passinf over a cemetery, he thought of something like a movable tent – a shelter over the ground, with flaps that might open and floorboards that, perhaps, have cracks. Now, apparently, this contamination goes straight up (and, according to those poskim, at least to 5000 feet). An airplane is pretty tightly built. It is a sturdy structure with a pressurized air cabin. There is an air intake, but it is indirect. So how would the contamination get in? Is the air intake at the exact bottom of the plane? More than likely, those Kohen get two or three sheets of metal, a carpet, a whole bunch of luggage, and their clothes (and airline seat) between them and this supposed contamination. Not to mention at least 5,000 feet of air (and, at cruising height, 35,000 feet). So what's the problem?

  17. The impurity goes straight up, like a laser, and bangs into the side of the plane. It stops there, so there's no need for plastic. The frumma are being silly.

  18. Junior Bear says:

    So, did he have his own air tank too. Wouldn't a breathing hole in the plastic still allow contamination under his thinking?

  19. Grace Acosta says:

    Considering how many times I get a cold or flu when flying, he may actually have the right idea! Still, taking Airborne during the flight is a bit less attention grabbing.

  20. It baffles me that no one seems to think this may possibly shed a very negative light on Jews…. Hello! Hillul Hashem much!?

  21. Gary Bennell says:

    The human condom… is this bloke for real?

  22. Angelina Ross says:

    um…I'm assuming he poked air holes in the bag so wouldn't that be letting in the impurities he's trying to protect himself from? I'm trying to apply logic to crazy again my bad!

  23. Anonymous says:

    Damn.. these fundamentalist Muslims… err wait…

  24. Anonymous says:

    Damn.. these fundamentalist Muslims… err wait…

  25. Anonymous says:

    What does he breathe ?!!

  26. bobbomo says:

    Monty Python could not have done better.

  27. Batsheva Bat-Avraham says:

    I also figured the airplane would be sufficient protection for the Kohen. What do I know?

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
The 13th issue of Al Qaeda's 'Inspire' online English-language magazine.
Al Qaeda Urges ‘Lone Wolves’ via Magazine to Attack US Airliners
Latest News Stories
Israeli Jewish teens have a very strong identity, partly due to their early bond with defending the Holy Land and its people.

United Synagogue Youth teen board members are told ban is lifted on dating non-Jews, but “important” to date within the faith.

The 13th issue of Al Qaeda's 'Inspire' online English-language magazine.

The latest edition of Al Qaeda’s online magazine urges lone wolf attacks on US airlines.

Jewish ritual slaughter is complex as it involves techniques that although ancient, are highly technical  to ensure the animal suffers no pain.

The Flemish Minister for Animal Welfare Ben Weyts has reversed his call for a ban on Jewish ritual slaughter in Belgium.

Michael Oren, Dec. 16, 2013.

Ambassador Michael Oren is the first person to join Moshe Kachlon’s new political party, Kulanu.

Israel issued a grim warning to Gaza’s ruling Hamas terrorists Wednesday over an attack that led to a major clash.

In case of a medical emergency, one should call the MDA hotline at 03-734-4005.

“Islamic State continues to try to take over more areas close to Iraq and Turkey,” Khatib said.

Beit Hadassah was built by Jews in 1893 as a local medical clinic.

Rosenblatt and several Jewish residents of the neighborhood visited the station on the seventh night of Chanukah to show their support after the murder Saturday of two police officers in neighboring Bedford-Stuyvesant.

Obama’s new attitude, as Gleijeses sees it, may have implications for the U.S. role in the Middle East and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Four PA Arabs with captured with pipe bombs on them.

Livni’s party is now down to 2 MKs (from 6). What did Herzog buy that was so expensive?

I’m going to recommend Velcro or sticky strips to Minister of Economy Naftali Bennett. He’s always checking to see if his Kipa fell off. In the photo are President of Israel, Ruby Rivlin (L) and Minister of Economy Naftali Bennett (R) during a “Outstanding Exporter” prize award ceremony held at the President’s residence in Jerusalem […]

The Prime Minister will appeal the decision by the party’s comptroller.

Hebrew University will give its students the day off on Christmas for the first time ever. There will be no classes on Thursday, Dec. 25, a new vacation day on the university calendar. The students also had off on Sunday for Hanukkah. The university also has declared a vacation day for and placed on its […]

Gross jailed for his work on USAid project.

More Articles from Tzvi Ben-Gedalyahu
Binyamin Netanyahu, barred, for the time being at least, from running to be re-elected party chairman.

The Prime Minister will appeal the decision by the party’s comptroller.

Israeli tanks and soldiers at  Gaza security barrier.

A Hamas commander was killed and the Air Force numbed terror targets.

Lieberman calls the police investigation a “witch-hunt” aimed at hurting the party’s chances at the polls.

“A great miracle happened here” –Yochanan Danziger and Jeff Seidel got out alive.

Bank Leumi’s admission is the first time an Israel bank has confessed to helping U.S. customers evade taxes.

Let’s hope Hamas fears Coca-Cola enough not to screw up in use the plant to shoot missiles at Israel.

It’s cute, inventive and raises an interesting question n Jewish law on appointing a representative to perform a mitzvah.

The results of the poll may cause people to start changing their minds.

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/plastic-bag-airplane-passenger-a-kohen-staying-pure/2013/04/12/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: