web analytics
August 1, 2014 / 5 Av, 5774
Israel at War: Operation Protective Edge
 
 
News & Views
Sponsored Post
Visiting IDF bases and receiving briefings from IDF officers. Ultimate Mission – November 2014

Don’t miss this opportunity to explore Israel off the beaten track, feel the conflict first hand, understand the security issues and politic realities, and have an unforgettable trip!



'HOLY PLASTIC!'

‘Plastic Bag’ Airplane Passenger a Kohen Staying Pure?

Look up in the sky? Is It a bird? Is it a plane? No, it’s Plastic Man – the Orthodox Jew who wrapped himself in plastic on an airplane, apparently because he is a very scrupulous Kohen.
plastic-man-on-airplane

An Orthodox Jewish man, wrapped in a plastic bag in his airline seat, apparently did so because he was probably a Kohen who went to extreme lengths to make sure he would not be ritually impure if the plane flew over a Jewish cemetery.

Kohenim are prohibited from coming into contact with dead bodies, and many rabbis have taken the strict opinion that a Kohen may not ride in a plane if he knows ahead of time that it will fly directly over a Jewish cemetery. Many have ruled that if does not know of the flight plan, he may ride in the airplane.

El Al once agreed to change a fight trajectory to avoid flying over a cemetery.

The man wrapped in plastic, whose photograph first appeared on the Redditor site and later on the Gothamist site, apparently did not want to take any chances. By covering himself in plastic, he established a separation between him and impurities.

However, since he arrived at his destination safe and sound, it can be assumed there was a hole in the plastic bag so he could breathe.

Some readers of Redditor suggested that “plastic man” was making sure he would not come into contact with the woman sitting behind him, but that is doubtful since it is unlikely he carried a plastic covering “just in case.”

Or maybe he simply wanted some attention.

About the Author: Tzvi Ben Gedalyahu is a graduate in journalism and economics from The George Washington University. He has worked as a cub reporter in rural Virginia and as senior copy editor for major Canadian metropolitan dailies. Tzvi wrote for Arutz Sheva for several years before joining the Jewish Press.


If you don't see your comment after publishing it, refresh the page.

Our comments section is intended for meaningful responses and debates in a civilized manner. We ask that you respect the fact that we are a religious Jewish website and avoid inappropriate language at all cost.

If you promote any foreign religions, gods or messiahs, lies about Israel, anti-Semitism, or advocate violence (except against terrorists), your permission to comment may be revoked.

27 Responses to “‘Plastic Bag’ Airplane Passenger a Kohen Staying Pure?”

  1. Lisa Liel says:

    See, and I thought it was a life-sized Hassid doll.

  2. Lisa Liel says:

    See, and I thought it was a life-sized Hassid doll.

  3. Josh Backon says:

    But these are gentile cemetaries ! See Yoreh Deah Siman 372 and Chelkat Yaakov I Siman 26 based on the Shach YD 372 s"k bet. Also Iggrot Moshe YD II 166. There is a klal: safek tumah bi'reshut ha'rabbim mutar. And here we're dealing with a POSSIBLE flight over a gentile cemetary. And even with a Jewish cemetary it's an issur d'rabbanan. The chilul hashem these idiots caused is much greater.

  4. Daniel Rosen says:

    If the insight in the article is based on a "probably" then how is this news? Does the writer know the facts of the story? The provenance of the picture? Has he interviewed those involved? Why is this a news story if it is conjecture? Is the article about religious experts who have issued rulings condoning or dondemning it? Is it an expose about the practices of El Al? I wouldn't know — I don't know what airline the guy in the picture is flying. Guess work is not journalism.

  5. Yehudis Gross says:

    How does he breathe?

  6. Raizy Fogel says:

    sorry, the picture doesn't look real, looks like a computer trick… stupid!

  7. Debbie Lee Burton says:

    I'm thinking about all those plastic bags that have warnings about keeping them away from children who might put it over their head and suffocate themselves. Now large bags will have to add warnings about adult Chasidim using them this way. I wonder how long a person can be in a bag before it is a health risk.

  8. Peter W. Singer says:

    This is what I would call a schmuck.

  9. Peter W. Singer says:

    This is what I would call a schmuck.

  10. Peter W. Singer says:

    This is what I would call a schmuck.

  11. Peter W. Singer says:

    Looks to me like a used body bag from the morgue.

  12. Kent Persson says:

    The fuselage of the aircraft ought to provide far better shielding agains Jewish cemeteries than a plastic bag with air holes.

  13. Yehuda Cohen says:

    Maybe there was a dead body on the plane. I have seen a casket put in first class and not in the bagage area. Only the family of that person sat in first class. More needs to be investigated and reported on this matter and not leave it to guess work as Daniel Rosen has stated otherwise an article like this opens people's mouths to Lashon Harah.

  14. Josh- go learn what "Hillul Hashem" is and what it is not. When it is an actual sin then it is a Hillul Hashem, when their is no sin it is not a Hillul Hashem. You also need to see how to talk about others and perhaps you need to make repentance in that regards before pointing the finger.

  15. Anonymous says:

    Has the "reporter" verified this story. The picture looks photo-shopped to me.

  16. The airplane should be adequate protection for the Kohen (i.e., the Rambam/Ramban was wrong and so are the poskim following him). The theory being followed by the poskim is that there is a form of contamination emitting from dead people that issues straight up into the sky. Apparently, one solution put forth is that concrete siding and a concrete lid can block this "contamination" from affecting the Kohen's ritual purity. When the Rambam thought of a vehicle passinf over a cemetery, he thought of something like a movable tent – a shelter over the ground, with flaps that might open and floorboards that, perhaps, have cracks. Now, apparently, this contamination goes straight up (and, according to those poskim, at least to 5000 feet). An airplane is pretty tightly built. It is a sturdy structure with a pressurized air cabin. There is an air intake, but it is indirect. So how would the contamination get in? Is the air intake at the exact bottom of the plane? More than likely, those Kohen get two or three sheets of metal, a carpet, a whole bunch of luggage, and their clothes (and airline seat) between them and this supposed contamination. Not to mention at least 5,000 feet of air (and, at cruising height, 35,000 feet). So what's the problem?

  17. The impurity goes straight up, like a laser, and bangs into the side of the plane. It stops there, so there's no need for plastic. The frumma are being silly.

  18. Junior Bear says:

    So, did he have his own air tank too. Wouldn't a breathing hole in the plastic still allow contamination under his thinking?

  19. Grace Acosta says:

    Considering how many times I get a cold or flu when flying, he may actually have the right idea! Still, taking Airborne during the flight is a bit less attention grabbing.

  20. It baffles me that no one seems to think this may possibly shed a very negative light on Jews…. Hello! Hillul Hashem much!?

  21. Gary Bennell says:

    The human condom… is this bloke for real?

  22. Angelina Ross says:

    um…I'm assuming he poked air holes in the bag so wouldn't that be letting in the impurities he's trying to protect himself from? I'm trying to apply logic to crazy again my bad!

  23. Anonymous says:

    Damn.. these fundamentalist Muslims… err wait…

  24. Anonymous says:

    Damn.. these fundamentalist Muslims… err wait…

  25. Anonymous says:

    What does he breathe ?!!

  26. bobbomo says:

    Monty Python could not have done better.

  27. Batsheva Bat-Avraham says:

    I also figured the airplane would be sufficient protection for the Kohen. What do I know?

Comments are closed.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

Current Top Story
An anti-Semitic poster seen in Europe.
Belgian Doctor to Jewish Woman: Go to Gaza, I Won’t Treat You
Latest News Stories
An anti-Semitic poster seen in Europe.

More ugly anti-Semitism in Europe, with the Gaza war serving as the wick for the firebombs of hatred.

caveman cease fire

Anyone taking bets on how long this cease fire will last, and how many rockets will be fired up to the last minute?

A site where a rocket hit in Ashdod, July 14, 2014.

As Gaza terrorists continue to ‘carpet-rocket’ Israel, UN chief Ban Ki-moon and US Secy of State John Kerry plan another cease fire.

Shuka Dorfman, head of the Israel Antiquities Authority, has passed away at 64 after a serious illness.

There can only be a finite number of tunnels, but the IDF keeps finding more of them…

Israel’s Chief Rabbis give ruling exempting IDF soldiers from fasting on Tisha B’Av.

8:00pm In the mortar attack on the Eshkol region, 10 people were wounded by a Gazan mortar, 6 in serious condition.

Life Lesson #1: Don’t go outside to photograph the Iron Dome system overhead if you don’t have to…

Obama has chosen shaky ally on the way out over strong ally solidly in the American orbit.

“Pro-Palestinian” activists continue to target Jews around the world; Aussie commentator: Where outrage about beheadings in Syria?

An Israeli-Arab Bedouin Sheikh arrives at Beer Sheva Saroka hospital yesterday to distribute flowers to wounded IDF soldiers. Each flower had a note attached to it, “We’re all in this together”.

Tourism Minister Dr. Uzi Landau likens Hamas and Israel with Al Qaeda and the United States; says “no talks with Hamas.”

Video: Residents of Ma’aleh Adumim catch Palestinians illegally entering Israel, report incident to police.

Eight were wounded midday Thursday when Hamas shelled the Eshkol district near the Gaza border.

Tourism Minister Uzi Landau compared Israel’s relationship with Hamas to America’s relationship with Al Qaeda.

More Articles from Tzvi Ben-Gedalyahu
idf rescue A wounded Israeli soldier is carried into Soroka hospital in the southern city of Beersheba  flash 90

Several soldiers were wounded as the IDF pounds Gaza and Hamas makes another ceasefire just another word.

he "Green Rock" system designed to provide an early warning before mortar shells hit their targets.

A radar system might stop mortar attacks, but that doesn’t change the truism that “the best defense is a good offense.”

“He had a hopped-up ‘cycle that took off like a gun/That fool was the terror of Highway 101 – ‘ from the song “Black Denim Trousers.”

Netanyahu and IDF Chief of Staff Gantz announce Israel will not stop the war until all terror tunnels are destroyed.

Hamas not only has no respect for the living but it also has no respect for the dead.

Kerry is consistent. He has talked so much and promised so much that, like the peace process, his ceasefire delivered nothing.

Hamas proposed a truce after rejecting it, and true to its principles, continued to fire at rockets at Israel.

Twenty Days, 30 terror tunnels destroyed and 2,200 rockets fired at Israel. The price: 43 soldiers.

    Latest Poll

    Do you think the FAA ban on US flights to Israel is political?






    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

Printed from: http://www.jewishpress.com/news/plastic-bag-airplane-passenger-a-kohen-staying-pure/2013/04/12/

Scan this QR code to visit this page online: